32 football legends pick Messi or Ronaldo as the GOAT as an era draws to a close

According to Mirror Football, a recent poll of 32 former players and coaches asked each legend to name who they consider the greatest of all time – Lionel Messi or Cristiano Ronaldo. The timing of the questionnaire coincides with two landmark moments in international football.

Messi announced his retirement from the Argentina national team earlier this year, closing a chapter that included a World Cup triumph and multiple Copa América titles. Ronaldo, meanwhile, has hinted that his Portugal career may be nearing its end after a decade of success that featured a Euro 2016 win and a Nations League trophy.

The poll results were evenly split, with half of the respondents backing Messi for his vision, dribbling and play‑making, while the other half favoured Ronaldo for his physical prowess, goal‑scoring record and longevity. No single legend dominated the vote, underscoring how subjective the GOAT discussion remains.

Both players have already secured a place among the sport’s most decorated figures, and their impending exits from international duty are prompting fans and pundits alike to reflect on their legacies. Readers can find related match highlights on this site.